Milton Coste

21 Brooklyn Heights Apartments with Fireplace

historic pre-war and luxury apartments with fireplaces in Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn

All NYC Brooklyn Heights
21 results
8 Pierrepont Street #3 For Sale 3D
Brian K Lewis at Compass
$999,000

1 bd · 1 ba · Co-op

8 Pierrepont Street #3, New York City

MLS: RLS20089439 RLS at REBNY
39 Schermerhorn Street For Sale
Barbara Wilding at Compass
$5,000,000

6 bd · 4 ba · 2,880 sqft · Multi Family

39 Schermerhorn Street, New York City

MLS: RLS20086569 RLS at REBNY
75 Columbia Heights For Sale 3D
Randy Baruh at Compass
$12,750,000

7 bd · 5 ba · 6,416 sqft · Multi Family

75 Columbia Heights, New York City

MLS: RLS20048753 RLS at REBNY
29 GARDEN Place For Sale
Ravi Kantha at Serhant
$13,495,000

5 bd · 5 ba · 5,150 sqft · Single Family Residence

29 GARDEN Place, New York City

MLS: RLS20026427 RLS at REBNY
122 STATE Street For Sale
Tita Omeze at Corcoran Group
$6,950,000

6 bd · 4 ba · 4,800 sqft · Multi Family

122 STATE Street, New York City

MLS: RLS20087695 RLS at REBNY
94 CLARK Street For Sale
Brandon Bogard at Serhant
$5,995,000

3 bd · 4 ba · Single Family Residence

94 CLARK Street, New York City

MLS: RLS20056821 RLS at REBNY
25 CRANBERRY Street For Sale 3D
Joan Goldberg at Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC
$4,900,000

4 bd · 2 ba · 3,263 sqft · Single Family Residence

25 CRANBERRY Street, New York City

MLS: RLS20085036 RLS at REBNY
12 MONROE Place For Sale
Jeffrey R Gallo at Corcoran Group
$9,200,000

7 bd · 6 ba · Multi Family

12 MONROE Place, New York City

MLS: RLS20083097 RLS at REBNY
99 Clinton Street #10 For Sale
John Moss at Hauseit LLC
$3,500,000

6 bd · 3 ba · 2,769 sqft · Co-op

99 Clinton Street #10, New York City

MLS: RLS20084482 RLS at REBNY
72 Poplar Street #PH For Sale
LINDSAY A BARRETT at Compass
$5,350,000

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,000 sqft · Condo

72 Poplar Street #PH, New York City

MLS: RLS20088112 RLS at REBNY
40 REMSEN Street #1 For Sale
Catherine Allen Leung Tanabe at Brown Harris Stevens Brooklyn LLC
$749,500

Studio · 1 ba · 698 sqft · Co-op

40 REMSEN Street #1, New York City

MLS: RLS20085230 RLS at REBNY
190 COLUMBIA Heights #4 For Sale
Nancy Giddins at Brown Harris Stevens Brooklyn LLC
$2,500,000

2 bd · 2 ba · Apartment

190 COLUMBIA Heights #4, New York City

MLS: RLS20086381 RLS at REBNY

Showing 12 of 21 apartments with fireplace

View All 21 Listings →

This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved.

Listings are updated approximately every 15 minutes. Data displayed by Keller Williams NYC.

RLS at REBNY

NYC Apartments With Fireplaces for Sale

Apartments with fireplaces for sale in NYC occupy a distinct corner of the market: pre-war co-ops and townhouse-style condos where original wood-burning hearths or gas-converted fireplaces serve as true architectural centerpieces. In my 25+ years selling Manhattan and Upper Manhattan apartments, I've seen a working fireplace consistently add negotiating power to a listing. Most wood-burning fireplaces are grandfathered units in pre-war buildings; new construction typically offers EPA-certified gas fireplaces instead. Browse our co-op listings, explore Upper West Side market data, or review co-op board interview tips.

Can I use a wood-burning fireplace in my NYC apartment?

It depends on construction date and DOB registration. Many pre-war co-ops retain grandfathered wood-burning fireplaces, but Local Law 43 places restrictions on high-pollution-alert days. Always ask the managing agent for the fireplace's DOB filing status before closing.

Which neighborhoods have the most fireplace apartments?

Pre-war co-op stock is densest along the Upper West Side, Upper East Side, Brooklyn Heights, and Park Slope. Hamilton Heights and Washington Heights also contain landmarked buildings with original fireplace mantels that have been carefully preserved.

Do fireplace apartments command a price premium?

Apartments with working fireplaces in Manhattan typically trade at a 3 to 8 percent premium. Gas-converted fireplaces add value primarily as a design feature, while original wood-burning units in landmarked buildings carry stronger pull with buyers.

Buying Tip from Milton Coste

Request a fireplace inspection as a contract contingency. Many older fireplaces have not been swept in years and may have compromised flue liners. A certified chimney sweep inspection costs $150-$300 and can uncover issues before closing. For gas units, ask for the ConEd service record to confirm the line is live.

Browse More Amenities

Doorman

Full-service living with 24-hour doorman and concierge
In-Unit Laundry

Skip the laundromat with in-unit washer and dryer
Pet-Friendly

NYC apartments that welcome your furry family members
Gym

Work out steps from your front door
Outdoor Space

Private terraces, balconies, and rooftop access
Parking

Dedicated parking in the city that never sleeps
Elevator

Easy access on every floor
Penthouse

Top-floor luxury with panoramic city views
Pool

Luxury living with swimming pool access
Concierge

White-glove service with dedicated concierge staff
HDFC

Income-restricted co-ops at below-market prices
Sponsor Unit

Buy direct from the sponsor, no board approval needed
Fixer-Upper

Renovation-ready properties with upside potential
Townhouse

Brownstones, rowhouses, and townhomes across NYC
New Construction

Brand-new apartments with modern finishes and tax abatements
Luxury

Premium residences starting at $2 million
Under $500K

Affordable apartments for first-time buyers
Pre-War

Classic NYC charm with high ceilings and original details
Loft

Open-plan living with soaring ceilings and exposed brick
Duplex

Two-level apartments with extra space and privacy
Investment

Multi-family buildings for owner-occupants and investors
Waterfront

River views and waterfront living across NYC
Short Sale

Below-market deals from motivated sellers

Apartments with Fireplace in Other Brooklyn Neighborhoods

WilliamsburgGreenpointBushwickBedford-StuyvesantCrown HeightsPark SlopeCobble HillCarroll GardensDUMBODowntown BrooklynFort GreeneClinton HillProspect HeightsBoerum HillGowanusRed HookSunset ParkBay RidgeBensonhurstFlatbush

Looking for Apartments with Fireplace in Brooklyn Heights?

I help buyers find apartments with the right amenities every week. Let me do the searching for you.

Call Text Email WhatsApp

Milton Coste, Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker, KWNYC