Milton Coste

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

(917) 416-7433

35 UNDERHILL AVENUE

Brooklyn · Prospect Heights · New York, NY 11238

Built 2005 6 Floors 39 Units Condominiums
A
100/100
Compliance Score

No open violations on record. Building is in full compliance.

What This Means for Buyers

35 UNDERHILL AVENUE is a mid-size modern condominiums building with walk-up in Prospect Heights. Prospect Heights is a compact Brooklyn neighborhood anchored by the Brooklyn Public Library, Grand Army Plaza, Prospect Park, and the Brooklyn Museum. The real estate market features historic brownsto... Zoned R6A, this building sits in a residential zoning district. The building has a clean compliance record with no open violations.

Prospect Heights

Prospect Heights is a compact Brooklyn neighborhood anchored by the Brooklyn Public Library, Grand Army Plaza, Prospect Park, and the Brooklyn Museum. The real estate market features historic brownstones, pre-war cooperatives, and new developments like Pacific Park, with 2/3/B/Q/4 train service.

View Full Neighborhood Profile

Public Records & Ownership Lookup

Search this building's deed history, mortgages, and LLC ownership through official NYC government databases. Free public data.

Permanent Property Identifier

BBL: 3-01131-7501

New to ACRIS? Read our step-by-step guide.

Looking to buy in this building?

See active sale listings in Prospect Heights and similar buildings nearby.

View Prospect Heights listings

Recently Rented in This Building

RLS Logo

Closed rental data from REBNY Listing Service (RLS). All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Sales History

Date Unit Beds Price Sq Ft
Nov 5, 2024Unit A5G2BR$1,830,0001,457
Dec 10, 2016Unit 4D2BRN/A1,281
Nov 16, 2017Unit A4A3BR$1,300,0001,275
Jun 2, 2017Unit 2B2BR$1,176,0001,198
Aug 23, 2018Unit A-6A2BR$1,450,0001,200
Oct 6, 2016Unit A-2E3BR$1,350,0001,474
Jun 9, 2017Unit B3G2BR$1,750,0001,940
Dec 29, 2017Unit 6C3BR$1,875,0001,479
Sep 9, 2015Unit A5C2BR$1,115,0001,200
Aug 7, 2015Unit A-5B2BR$1,135,0001,341
Sep 24, 2015Unit B1H3BR$1,525,0001,885
May 17, 2022Unit B-4G2BR$1,450,0001,239
Sep 12, 2014Unit B4H2BRN/A1,156
Feb 25, 2021Unit 3-D2BR$1,330,0001,296
Apr 30, 2021Unit B-3G3BR$1,975,0001,942
Apr 3, 2020Unit A-4B2BR$1,300,0001,198
Mar 2, 2026Unit B4I2BR$1,810,0001,167
Sep 30, 2025Unit B4G2BR$1,787,5001,239
Sep 29, 2023Unit B2H2BR$1,481,0001,156
Mar 21, 2022Unit A-4E3BR$1,625,0001,474
Sep 8, 2022Unit B3I2BR$1,660,0001,491
Dec 17, 2020Unit B1H3BR$1,625,0001,885
Jun 29, 2021Unit B2I2BR$1,388,0001,296
Jul 22, 2017Unit A-5D3BRN/A1,556
Dec 22, 2020Unit A6C3BR$1,995,0001,479
Jul 7, 2021Unit A5A2BR$1,605,0001,498
Jul 19, 2013Unit A/6A2BRN/A-
Sep 27, 2021Unit PHB4I2BR$1,650,000-
Oct 28, 2021Unit A-3E3BR$1,675,0001,474
RLS

Closed sale data from REBNY Listing Service. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Rental History

Unit Lease Date Rent Beds Baths Sq Ft
Unit A-3CJul 5, 2023$6,000/mo321,419
Unit A-2EOct 13, 2017$4,750/mo321,474
Unit A-2CJul 15, 2016$5,250/mo321,419
Unit A-6AMay 1, 2016$5,000/mo221,200
Unit A-3CAug 10, 2023$7,400/mo321,419
Unit B-4GApr 21, 2017$4,200/mo221,228
Unit 4BMay 15, 2022$6,000/mo221,200
Unit A-5BDec 11, 2012$3,800/mo221,341
Unit A4ESep 27, 2013$4,400/mo321,475
Unit 6BJul 27, 2022$9,400/mo321,733
Unit A-2ENov 5, 2016$4,750/mo321,474
Unit 6BMay 29, 2014$5,500/mo321,700
Unit A-2COct 24, 2020$5,300/mo321,419
Unit A-2ESep 27, 2020$5,000/mo321,474
Unit 5GMar 11, 2020$5,400/mo221,457
Unit A-5GJun 8, 2020$5,000/mo221,457
Unit 6-BJul 7, 2019$7,500/mo321,730
RLS

Closed rental data from REBNY Listing Service. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Compliance & Violations

Clean Compliance Record

This building has no open violations on record with NYC DOB or HPD.

Source: NYC Department of Buildings & HPD (data.cityofnewyork.us)

Nearby Transit

No subway stations found within 0.5 miles.

Approximate walking distances.

Nearby Schools

No public schools found within walking distance.

Permits & Renovations

No recent permit filings found.

Zoning & Development

Zoning District
R6A

Residential zoning district.

Overlay
C2-4
Floor Area Ratio (FAR)
3.60 / 3.00
Fully built or over-built

Building Details

Physical
Building Class
Condominiums (RM)
Land Use
4
Year Built
2005
Floors
6
Buildings on Lot
2
Total Units
40
Residential Units
39
Gross Floor Area
60,626 sq ft
Lot Area
16,825 sq ft
Lot Frontage
115.17 ft
Lot Depth
120.17 ft
Municipal Districts
Community District
CD 8
City Council
District 35
School District
13
Police Precinct
77
Fire Company
E219
Sanitation District
8
BBL
3011317501.00000000

Source: NYC PLUTO (data.cityofnewyork.us)

Street View

Location

Building Subway 🏫 Elementary 📚 Middle 🎓 High School

Frequently Asked Questions about 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE

What kind of building is 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
35 UNDERHILL AVENUE is recorded in NYC PLUTO as a Condominiums (building class RM).
When was 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE built?
Built in 2005, 6 floors, 40 total units. Data sourced from NYC PLUTO, the city's official tax lot database.
How many units are at 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
39 residential units across 6 floors. The building also contains 1 commercial or non-residential unit.
How many apartments are currently for sale at 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
Active listing counts are loaded from the REBNY Listing Service in real time. See the Active Listings section above for current availability and price ranges. If no listings appear, there are no units currently on the market through RLS.
What is the average price per square foot at 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
Per-square-foot pricing is calculated from closed sale transactions in the Sales History section above. Actual pricing varies by floor, exposure, renovation level, and unit layout. For a current valuation, contact Milton for a building-specific comparable market analysis.
What is the closest subway to 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
35 UNDERHILL AVENUE is served by MTA subway lines within BK. The Nearby Transit section above shows all stations within half a mile.
How can I see the full sales history for 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
The Sales History section on this page shows closed transactions from the REBNY Listing Service (RLS). For full deed and mortgage history back to 1966, including lien searches and ownership chain verification, use ACRIS, NYC's free official property records system. Our step-by-step guide explains exactly how: ACRIS NYC: How to Search Deeds, Liens & Owner Records Free.
Who should I contact about a listing at 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
Milton Coste, Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker at Keller Williams NYC. Call or text (917) 416-7433, email [email protected], or schedule a consultation online. Milton has represented buyers and sellers across all five boroughs for 25+ years.
Who owns 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
The current owner of 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE is recorded in the most recent deed on file with the NYC Department of Finance ACRIS system. To find the current owner: (1) visit acris.nyc.gov, (2) search by BBL 3-01131-7501 or by address, (3) sort by date descending and find the most recent deed. The grantee (buyer) on that deed is the current owner. If the owner is an LLC, look up the LLC's managing member at the NY Department of State Business Entity Database.
What is the BBL for 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
The BBL (Borough, Block, Lot) for 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE is 3-01131-7501. The first digit (3) identifies the borough: Brooklyn. The next 5 digits are the tax block (1131) and the last 4 are the lot within that block (7501). BBLs never change even when addresses are renumbered, which makes them the most reliable identifier for NYC public records like ACRIS deeds, DOB permits, and tax bills.
Where can I find the deed history for 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?
Every recorded deed for 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE since 1966 is searchable for free at acris.nyc.gov. Search by BBL 3-01131-7501 for the most reliable results. The deed history shows every ownership transfer with grantor (seller), grantee (buyer), date, and recorded sale price. Older transfers may show LLC names. To trace the LLC's managing member, cross-reference with the NY Department of State at apps.dos.ny.gov. Our step-by-step ACRIS guide walks through the full process.

Interested in 35 UNDERHILL AVENUE?

Milton Coste is a Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker at Keller Williams NYC with 25+ years across all five boroughs. Call, text, or schedule a free consultation.

Call Text Valuation