Milton Coste

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

(917) 416-7433

SOLD FOR $2,499,000

· Closed March 6, 2023

540 E 23rd Street
Looking for something similar?

$2,499,000

$964 per sq ft

540 E 23rd Street

Flatbush, Brooklyn

MLS® #RLS10834829

RLS at REBNY

Listing by Compass

5

Bedrooms

4

Baths

2,592

Sq. Ft.

1910

Year Built

Quick Summary

Bedrooms 5
Bathrooms 4
Living Area 2,592 sq ft
Year Built 1910
Parking Garage
Neighborhood Flatbush

Property Highlights

  • Style: Prewar architecture
  • Parking: Private garage
  • Character: Pre-war building (1910)

Property Details

Type Single Family Residence
Total Rooms 13
Baths 4 Full
Pets Yes
Cross Street Foster Avenue/Farragut Road
Year Built 1910
Living Area 2,592 sq ft
Parking Garage Available
Architectural Style Prewar
Parcel # 05222-0025
Block/Lot 5222/25

Description

Brimming with charm and enchantment, the idyllic setting of this 5 Bedroom, 3 Full and 2 Half Bath Victorian is something out of a fairytale! Everything you could wish for has been done for you! Completely renovated inside and out, this enchanting beauty has been beautifully redesigned to maximize open space and light while showcasing the lovely original detail and the breathtaking structure beneath. Glimpses of rough-hewn joists and exposed brick, combine effortlessly with the crisp lines of the lofty, light filled interior, creating a wonderfully organic and unmistakably inviting aesthetic. The gracious front porch with two ceiling fans to cool you on hot, Summer days welcomes you into the sprawling, dramatic open space of the Parlor floor. An absolute dream for family life and gatherings, the generous entry foyer, living/dining areas and kitchen flow together seamlessly. Ten foot ceilings enhance the feeling of open space and windows on every wall flood the room with spectacular natural light while affording a lovely connection to the outdoors. The sprawling entry foyer and living room are big enough for two seating areas, and has a bay of three windows, the original decorative, gas fireplace and an original leaded glass window. The dining room is big enough for a table that seats 10 or more, has another decorative gas fireplace and is open to the stunning chef's kitchen. Exquisite kitchen finishes include custom white painted cabinetry with Santana Quartz countertops, an integrated gold toned Farm sink and fixtures. The high end appliance suite includes an LG Cafe Series, 6-burner stove with a white Ancona hood, Bosch dishwasher and a huge Frigidaire, double door refrigerator with a full size refrigerator and freezer. Rough hewn, open shelving and exposed beam ceilings add a delightful organic contrast. A door off of the kitchen to your private backyard oasis with a large expanse of grass and peripheral plantings, makes enjoyment of the outdoors easy! Off of the kitchen is a convenient, windowed half bath. The perfectly laid out second floor is the home to three, huge bedrooms and two full baths. The big and bright Primary suite can accommodate a King sized bed with plenty of room to spare, has a huge walk-in closet that awaits your customization and a spa-like ensuite bath. Luxurious bath finishes include a gorgeous, double sink vanity with gold toned fixtures and great cabinet and drawers storage, a huge, open, walk in shower with gold toned rain shower head and hand held shower, and a free standing soaking tub. The second full bath has a shower/tub combo with gold toned rain shower head and hand held shower, whimsical black and white floor tile and a blue painted wood vanity. The sunny, third floor bath has dark blue vanity, lovely wood floors and a shower/tub combo with gold toned rain shower head and hand held shower. The finished basement is a fantastic bonus additional living space, ripe for your finishing touches. An open stair from the Parlor floor allows for fluid integration into the rest of the home and is Complete with vinyl plank flooring, a half bath and laundry area with LG Thin Q front loading washer & dryer. Whether it is a home gym or office, screening room or playroom, the possibilities are endless! Con Edison high efficiency, Hyper Heat system provides perfect climate control heating and cooling throughout the home. The long driveway with one car garage can easily accommodate three cars! All of this in close proximity to the new playground on Bedford and Glenwood, Midwood Montessori, PS 315, PS 889, PS 193, Midwood High School, the vibrant shopping and restaurants of Flatbush Junction, Newkirk Plaza and Cortelyou Road!e shopping and restaurants of Cortelyou Rd, Newkirk Plaza and the 2, 5, B & Q trains to Manhattan.

Features & Amenities

Exterior Features

Building Garden Garden

Building Information

Stories 2
Style Prewar

Flatbush features one of Brooklyn's most varied housing stocks, including grand detached Victorians along Ocean Avenue, limestone and brownstone rowhouses, prewar apartment buildings, and brick townhomes within landmarked enclaves like Prospect Park South and Ditmas Park. The Q, 2, and 5 trains connect the neighborhood to Manhattan, while Prospect Park's 526 acres of green space border the northern edge. The restored Kings Theatre, a 1920s-era landmark performance venue, and Erasmus Hall High School, founded in 1786, are among the area's most notable architectural features.

Flatbush Live Market Data

View Neighborhood

Active Listings

40

Median Asking Price

$512K

Median $/Sqft

$480

Avg Days on Market

N/A

New This Week

2

Price Reduced

33%

Sold (30 Days)

4

Median Sale Price

$464K

Live data from RLS at REBNY • Updated 3/23/26, 6:07 PM EST

Similar Listings in Flatbush

View All

Location

Loading map...

540 E 23rd Street, Flatbush, Kings County • Near Foster Avenue/Farragut Road

Floor Plans

Floor Plan
Floor Plan
Floor Plan
Floor Plan
Floor Plan
MLS® ID: RLS10834829
First Listed: 9/7/2022
Price Changed: 11/7/2022
Closed: 3/6/2023
Contract Date: 5/18/2022

Listing Courtesy of Compass - Laura Rozos

Listing Contact: (917) 701-7340

Listing information for certain New York City properties provided courtesy of the Real Estate Board of New York's Residential Listing Service (the "RLS"). The information contained in this listing has not been verified by the RLS and should be verified by the consumer. The listing information provided here is for the consumer's personal, non-commercial use. Retransmission, redistribution or copying of this listing information is strictly prohibited except in connection with a consumer's consideration of the purchase and/or sale of an individual property. This listing information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., all rights reserved. This advertisement does not suggest that the broker has a listing in this property or properties or that any property is currently available.

Broker Commission Disclosure: Broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable.

Buyer Notice: Planning to work with a buyer's broker? A Buyer Representation Agreement is required before your broker can show you properties, per REBNY/UCBA guidelines (effective 2025). You may attend open houses independently without one.

RLS at REBNY

RLS Data display by Keller Williams NYC. Data last updated on 3/23/2026 at 10:07 PM UTC

Buying in NYC? Start Here

NYC Closing Costs: Complete Breakdown

Buyer and seller closing costs itemized, including what to budget for.

Read article

NYC Mansion Tax: 2026 Guide

How the tiered mansion tax works for purchases over $1M.

Read article

NYC Real Estate Market Report 2026

Data-driven analysis of prices, inventory, and trends across NYC.

Read article

Interested in this property?

Get a response within 2 hours

Your info is secure and never shared.

View Active Listings Call Milton