On April 20, 2024, Governor Kathy Hochul signed Good Cause Eviction into state law, and it took effect immediately, altering the rules for millions of market-rate rental units across New York. For landlords and investors, this is not a distant policy change: it affects how you raise rents, how you remove tenants, and how you underwrite income property today.
In my 25-plus years working with buyers, sellers, and investors across all five boroughs, I have watched rent regulation expand incrementally. Good Cause is the broadest extension of tenant protections to market-rate units in a generation.
What Good Cause Eviction Does
Rent increase cap: For covered units, landlords may not raise rent by more than 10% per year, or CPI plus 5%, whichever is lower. With CPI running around 3-4%, the effective ceiling has been roughly 8-9% annually.
Eviction restrictions: Landlords must state a specific lawful reason to non-renew a lease. Accepted grounds include nonpayment, substantial lease violations, nuisance, owner or family use, and building demolition.
NYC Investment Properties
Multi-family properties for landlords and investors
4612 Murdock Avenue
Wakefield
12 MONROE Place
Brooklyn Heights
Listing information provided courtesy of the Real Estate Board of New York's Residential Listing Service (RLS). Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Sale listings verified. ©2026 REBNY. RLS data displayed by Keller Williams NYC.
Which Properties Are Covered
| Property Type | Covered? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Market-rate units, 10+ unit buildings | Yes | Core coverage |
| Rent-stabilized units | No | Already governed by ETPA |
| New construction (within 30 years) | No | 30-year exemption window |
| Owner-occupied, 10 or fewer units | No | Small landlord exemption |
| Condos/co-ops, owner-occupied | No | Does not apply to owner-occupants |
| Subsidized housing (LIHTC, Section 8) | No | Separate federal/state programs |
Rent Increase Cap in Practice
With CPI averaging around 3.5% through 2025, the effective annual cap for most covered units is approximately 8.5% (3.5% + 5%). The law sets 10% as an absolute ceiling regardless of inflation.
How This Changes Multifamily Underwriting
Good Cause adds a ceiling to the revenue growth side of the NOI equation. In the Bronx, where co-ops and small multifamily buildings trade at cap rates in the 4-to-5% range, investors who underwrote aggressive rent bumps on covered buildings need to revise those projections.
Audit Your Portfolio
- Confirm which buildings have 10 or more units
- Identify all market-rate tenancies
- Check construction date against 30-year window
- Note any owner-occupied units
Update Your Lease Process
- Calculate the lower of 10% or CPI + 5% before renewals
- Document basis for any non-renewal in writing
- Consult housing attorney for owner-use grounds
- Revise renewal templates for compliance
Evaluating a Multifamily Investment?
Milton Coste has 25+ years of experience across all five boroughs and can help you assess Good Cause exposure before you close.
Schedule a Free ConsultationFor buyers evaluating Queens and Brooklyn multifamily properties, the exemption analysis should be part of every due diligence checklist. See the NYC market report index covering all 169 neighborhoods.
Search NYC Investment Properties
Search NYC Properties
