Fair Housing Notice
Milton Coste

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

Search MLS
Buy Sell Rent
For Sale For Rent
Track Record Map Search Buildings About Contact

Market Reports

NYC Neighborhoods Hudson Valley
Knowledge Center

FAQs, Guides & Resources
Blog Buying FAQ Renting FAQ

Guides & Presentations

Buyer's Guide Seller's Guide Renter's Guide Landlord Guide
(917) 416-7433
Sutton Place Real Estate - Homes for Sale

Sutton Place Real Estate

225 properties for sale

About Sutton Place

Sutton Place is a secluded and prestigious residential enclave known for its quiet elegance and stunning East River views. This neighborhood offers a 'small-town' feel within the city, defined by its private parks and classic architecture. The housing stock is predominantly composed of grand, white-glove cooperatives, many of which feature expansive layouts and historic details that appeal to discerning buyers seeking privacy.

Milton Coste - Sutton Place Real Estate Expert

Your Sutton Place Expert

Milton Coste was born and raised in the Washington Heights/Inwood area and has been helping buyers and sellers in Upper Manhattan and across NYC for over 25 years. With 1,000+ closed transactions including dozens in Sutton Place, Milton knows every building, every block, and what it takes to navigate NYC's unique co-op and condo market.

1,000+ Deals Closed 5.0★ Google & Zillow Hablo Español

Frequently Asked Questions: Sutton Place Real Estate

Who is the best real estate agent in Sutton Place?
Milton Coste is a top-rated Sutton Place real estate specialist with 25+ years of experience and 1,000+ closed transactions in NYC. Born and raised in the Washington Heights area, Milton has deep local knowledge of Sutton Place's co-ops, condos, and market trends. He's bilingual (English/Spanish) and has a 5-star rating on both Google and Zillow. Contact: (917) 416-7433 or [email protected].
What are Sutton Place apartment prices in 2026?
Sutton Place real estate prices vary by property type. As of January 2026, co-op studios typically start around $250,000-$400,000, 1-bedrooms range from $350,000-$600,000, and 2-bedrooms from $450,000-$800,000. Condos command a premium of 20-40% over co-ops. Milton Coste tracks Sutton Place prices daily and can provide a detailed market analysis for your specific needs.
What is the process for buying a co-op in Sutton Place?
Buying a co-op in Sutton Place involves several steps: getting pre-approved for financing, searching for properties, making an offer, preparing a board package (financial documents, reference letters, personal statement), and passing the co-op board interview. The process typically takes 60-90 days from accepted offer to closing. Milton Coste guides buyers through each step and has helped over 1,000 clients navigate NYC's co-op and condo market.

What Clients Say

View All Reviews

"Milton helped us buy our first home in Washington Heights. He knew the neighborhood inside and out, negotiated a great price, and guided us through every step of the closing process."

Maria R.

Buyer • Washington Heights

$25K under asking

"Milton is excellent - my apartment transition went absolutely seamless, and quick! He is very responsive and was extremely informed about both my property and the area."

Tim W.

Seller • Washington Heights

Sold in 45 days
Google
5.0
Google Reviews
Zillow
5.0
Zillow Reviews
Read All Reviews →

Current Inventory Snapshot

Live from REBNY/RLS • Feb 15, 2026

There are currently 225 properties actively listed for sale, with 115 already under contract. The median asking price is $1.20M ($1,148/sqft). Properties are spending an average of N/A days on market, and 35.1% of listings have had price reductions.

Inventory & Activity

Active Listings

225

for sale

Total number of properties currently for sale in this neighborhood

Pending Sales

115

under contract

Properties under contract awaiting closing

New This Week

8

last 7 days

Properties listed in the last 7 days

New This Month

47

last 30 days

Properties listed in the last 30 days

Avg Days on Market

N/A

days avg

Average number of days properties have been listed. Lower = faster market

Price Cut Rate

35.1%

79 listings

Percentage of active listings with price reductions. Higher = more negotiable market

Asking Prices

Median Asking Price

$1.20M

all types

The middle price point of all active listings - half are priced above, half below

Average Asking Price

$2.69M

all types

Mean listing price of all active properties (can be skewed by outliers)

Median $/Sqft

$1,148

per sqft

Median price per square foot - useful for comparing properties of different sizes

Median Condo Price

$3.00M

64 condos

Median asking price for condominium units only

Median Co-op Price

$968K

158 co-ops

Median asking price for co-operative units only

Property Mix

Distribution of 225 active listings
Condo 28% (64) Co-op 70% (158) Condop 0% (1)

Building Types:

Apartments: 217 Single Family: 2 Multi-Family: 6

Recent Sales

Sold (30 Days)

13

last 30 days

Number of properties that closed in the last 30 days

Sold (90 Days)

56

last 90 days

Number of properties that closed in the last 90 days

Median Sale Price

$1.06M

closed sales

Median closing price of recently sold properties (last 90 days)

Avg Sale Price

$1.43M

closed sales

Average closing price of recently sold properties

Sale-to-List Ratio

100.0%

of asking

Average sale price as % of listing price. Above 100% = selling over asking

Browse by Property Type

Co-ops (40) Condos (7) Condops (1)

Buildings in Sutton Place

50 Sutton Place

3 listings available

321 54th Street

2 listings available

425 58TH Street

2 listings available

60 Sutton Place

2 listings available

220 54TH Street

2 listings available

153 57TH Street

2 listings available

Properties for Sale

225 listings

Advanced Search
321 E 54th Street #10B
Active
$579,000
Mid-rise
12

321 E 54th Street #10B

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1929
RLS #RLS11027497
View Details
425 E 58TH Street #42B
Active
$2,200,000
High-rise
8

425 E 58TH Street #42B

Sutton Place

2 bed 3 bath 1,800 sqft
Co-op · 1975
RLS #RLS20072125
View Details
250 E 54TH Street #28C
Active
$1,130,000
High-rise
14

250 E 54TH Street #28C

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath 788 sqft
Condo · 1990
RLS #RLS20050427
View Details
420 E 55TH Street #9L
Active
$615,000
Mid-rise
6

420 E 55TH Street #9L

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath 770 sqft
Co-op · 1956
RLS #RLS20068038
View Details
441 E 57TH Street #4
Active
$1,195,000
Mid-rise
15

441 E 57TH Street #4

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath 1,716 sqft
Condo · 2009
RLS #RLS20068699
View Details
36 SUTTON Place #2D
Active
$750,000
Mid-rise
9

36 SUTTON Place #2D

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath 1,100 sqft
Co-op · 1949
RLS #RLS20051059
View Details
60 Sutton Place #7-KN
Active
$1,399,000
Mid-rise
19

60 Sutton Place #7-KN

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1952
RLS #RLS20068365
View Details
220 E 54TH Street #10D
Active
$655,000
Mid-rise
17

220 E 54TH Street #10D

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1962
RLS #RLS20054021
View Details
220 E 54TH Street #6A
Active
$595,000
Mid-rise
19

220 E 54TH Street #6A

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1962
RLS #RLS20057888
View Details
60 SUTTON Place #8GN
Active
$800,000
Mid-rise
13

60 SUTTON Place #8GN

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1951
RLS #RLS20070250
View Details
227 E 57TH Street #19C
Active
$649,000
Mid-rise
42

227 E 57TH Street #19C

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1930
RLS #RLS20070955
View Details
209 E 56TH Street #2K
Active
$399,000
Mid-rise
9

209 E 56TH Street #2K

Sutton Place

0 bed 1 bath 560 sqft
Co-op · 1960
RLS #RLS20045948
View Details
425 E 58TH Street #22H
Active
$2,799,000
High-rise
17

425 E 58TH Street #22H

Sutton Place

4 bed 4 bath 2,800 sqft
Co-op · 1975
RLS #RLS20070235
View Details
153 E 57TH Street #6A
Active
$499,000
High-rise
8

153 E 57TH Street #6A

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath 725 sqft
Co-op · 1959
RLS #RLS20055503
View Details
400 E 59th Street #3-A
Active
$759,000
Mid-rise
14

400 E 59th Street #3-A

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath 770 sqft
Co-op · 1928
RLS #RLS20047774
View Details
440 E 56TH Street #1B
Active
$1,249,500
Mid-rise
8

440 E 56TH Street #1B

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1955
RLS #RLS20068650
View Details
313 E 56th Street #2C
Active
$700,000
Low-rise
7

313 E 56th Street #2C

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1901
RLS #RLS20060271
View Details
400 E 54th Street #8A
Active
$999,000
High-rise
19

400 E 54th Street #8A

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath 1,053 sqft
Condo · 1972
RLS #RLS20051921
View Details
350 E 54TH Street #3H
Active
$710,000
Low-rise
4

350 E 54TH Street #3H

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath 727 sqft
Condo · 1941
RLS #RLS20059930
View Details
447 E 57TH Street #14
Active
$3,995,000
Mid-rise
16

447 E 57TH Street #14

Sutton Place

5 bed 6 bath 4,120 sqft
Co-op · 1928
RLS #RLS20062399
View Details
40 Sutton Place #4J
Active
$750,000
Mid-rise
7

40 Sutton Place #4J

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath 605 sqft
Condo · 1966
RLS #RLS20069340
View Details
220 E 57TH Street #4C
Active
$410,000
High-rise
12

220 E 57TH Street #4C

Sutton Place

0 bed 1 bath 600 sqft
Co-op · 1970
RLS #RLS20018451
View Details
321 E 54th Street #3D
Active
$330,000
Mid-rise
6

321 E 54th Street #3D

Sutton Place

0 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1929
RLS #RLS20067932
View Details
25 SUTTON Place #16L
Active
$750,000
High-rise
11

25 SUTTON Place #16L

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath 1,000 sqft
Co-op · 1959
RLS #RLS20065749
View Details
357 E 57th Street #5C
Active
$450,000
Mid-rise
12

357 E 57th Street #5C

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1958
RLS #RLS20066498
View Details
433 E 56th Street #6-B
Active
$749,000
Mid-rise
9

433 E 56th Street #6-B

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1967
RLS #RLS20027002
View Details
200 E 57TH Street #18M
Active
$985,000
High-rise
6

200 E 57TH Street #18M

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1960
RLS #RLS20059611
View Details
25 Sutton Place #9R
Active
$695,000
High-rise
11

25 Sutton Place #9R

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath 1,000 sqft
Co-op · 1959
RLS #RLS20060727
View Details
212 E 57TH Street #21A
Active
$2,700,000
High-rise
10

212 E 57TH Street #21A

Sutton Place

3 bed 4 bath 1,923 sqft
Condo · 2004
RLS #RLS20071711
View Details
50 Sutton Place #2D
Active
$550,000
Mid-rise
10

50 Sutton Place #2D

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1955
RLS #RLS11026134
View Details
300 E 59TH Street #607
Active
$1,195,000
High-rise
14

300 E 59TH Street #607

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1974
RLS #RLS20059587
View Details
333 E 53RD Street #10C
Active
$620,000
Mid-rise
10

333 E 53RD Street #10C

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1929
RLS #RLS20010707
View Details
200 E 57TH Street #6H
Active
$945,000
High-rise
8

200 E 57TH Street #6H

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1960
RLS #RLS20052587
View Details
400 E 59TH Street #14F
Active
$530,000
Mid-rise
10

400 E 59TH Street #14F

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1929
RLS #RLS20046482
View Details
153 E 57TH Street #9GH
Active
$995,000
High-rise
5

153 E 57TH Street #9GH

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath 1,300 sqft
Co-op · 1959
RLS #RLS20056065
View Details
252 E 57TH Street #55A
Active
$6,295,000
High-rise
14

252 E 57TH Street #55A

Sutton Place

3 bed 3 bath 2,626 sqft
Condo · 2017
RLS #RLS20049350
View Details
303 E 57TH Street #6AB
Active
$720,000
High-rise
14

303 E 57TH Street #6AB

Sutton Place

2 bed 3 bath 2,000 sqft
Co-op · 1968
RLS #RLS20044652
View Details
419 E 57TH Street #6F
Active
$1,595,000
Mid-rise
12

419 E 57TH Street #6F

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1927
RLS #RLS20070208
View Details
211 E 53RD Street #6A
Active
$625,000
Mid-rise
8

211 E 53RD Street #6A

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath 750 sqft
Condop · 1959
RLS #RLS20071134
View Details
45 SUTTON Place #16/O
Active
$895,000
High-rise
10

45 SUTTON Place #16/O

Sutton Place

1 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1958
RLS #RLS20071441
View Details
45 Sutton Place #8L
Active
$1,700,000
High-rise
21

45 Sutton Place #8L

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1958
RLS #RLS20036943
View Details
245 E 54TH Street #17G
Active
$595,000
High-rise
10

245 E 54TH Street #17G

Sutton Place

1 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1977
RLS #RLS20062259
View Details
50 Sutton Place #11L
Active
$1,100,000
Mid-rise
10

50 Sutton Place #11L

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath
Co-op · 1955
RLS #RLS20059617
View Details
400 E 56TH Street #38L
Active
$1,599,999
High-rise
26

400 E 56TH Street #38L

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath 1,416 sqft
Co-op · 1969
RLS #RLS20059122
View Details
220 E 57TH Street #5G
Active
$375,000
High-rise
7

220 E 57TH Street #5G

Sutton Place

0 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1970
RLS #RLS20066638
View Details
400 E 56TH Street #26L
Active
$1,475,000
High-rise
13

400 E 56TH Street #26L

Sutton Place

2 bed 2 bath 1,416 sqft
Co-op · 1969
RLS #RLS20050139
View Details
339 E 58th Street #9H
Active
$295,000
Mid-rise
6

339 E 58th Street #9H

Sutton Place

0 bed 1 bath
Co-op · 1930
RLS #RLS20067995
View Details
50 Sutton Place #21L
Active
$1,495,000
Mid-rise
11

50 Sutton Place #21L

Sutton Place

3 bed 3 bath
Co-op · 1955
RLS #RLS20057685
View Details

Explore Nearby Neighborhoods

Upper West Side Upper East Side Tribeca Chelsea

Helpful Resources for Sutton Place Buyers

NYC Buyer's Guide

Step-by-step buying process

Buyer Presentation

What to expect working with Milton

NYC Real Estate FAQ

Common questions answered

Looking to Buy or Sell in Sutton Place?

With 25+ years of experience and 1,000+ deals closed, Milton Coste is your trusted Sutton Place expert. Get a free consultation today.

Schedule Free Call WhatsApp
Call Milton WhatsApp