Milton Coste

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

Search MLS
Buy Sell Neighborhoods

Property Types

Condos Co-ops New Dev Single Family Multi-Family Coming Soon Recently Sold Condops New to Market Price Drops Compare
New to Market For Sale Map Open Houses
Apartments Near... By Amenity
Track Record Buildings About Contact

My Markets

Wash Heights Inwood Hamilton Hts Harlem Hudson Hts All Reports

Boroughs

Manhattan Brooklyn Queens Hudson Valley
Knowledge Center

FAQs, Guides & Resources
Blog Buying FAQ Selling FAQ

Guides & Presentations

Buyer's Guide Seller's Guide Renter's Guide Landlord Guide Landlord Guide
(917) 416-7433

Recently Sold in City Island

24 closed sales in City Island, Bronx

Explore recent closing prices to understand current market values and comp data.

Recent Sales in City Island

Closed sales data is essential for understanding real market values in City Island. Unlike asking prices, closing prices reflect what buyers actually paid after negotiation. Use this data for comparable sales analysis when pricing a home or making an offer.

Thinking about selling? Get a free property valuation from Milton Coste, or view the City Island market report for current trends.

25 Bay Street Closed

$780,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 2 ba |1,500 sqft

25 Bay Street

City Island

R New York RLS
551 Minnieford Avenue Closed

$848,000

Single Family Residence
4 bd | 2 ba |1,851 sqft

551 Minnieford Avenue

City Island

R New York RLS
8 Tier Street Closed

$1,550,000

Multi Family
4 bd | 2 ba |2,400 sqft

8 Tier Street

City Island

R New York RLS
723 KING Avenue Closed

$625,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 2 ba |1,400 sqft

723 KING Avenue

City Island

Corcoran Group RLS
5 Windward Lane #5 Closed

$686,800

Condo
2 bd | 3 ba |1,639 sqft

5 Windward Lane #5

City Island

R New York RLS
16 Tier Street Closed

$1,250,000

Single Family Residence
5 bd | 3 ba |2,535 sqft

16 Tier Street

City Island

R New York RLS
73 Caroll Street Closed

$767,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 2 ba |1,620 sqft

73 Caroll Street

City Island

R New York RLS
51 ISLAND Point #51 Closed

$775,000

Condo
3 bd | 4 ba |1,969 sqft

51 ISLAND Point #51

City Island

Douglas Elliman Real Estate RLS
383 KING Avenue Closed

$660,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 3 ba |2,040 sqft

383 KING Avenue

City Island

Corcoran Group RLS
148 Reville Street Closed

$675,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 2 ba |1,424 sqft

148 Reville Street

City Island

R New York RLS
38 Tier Street Closed

$646,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 2 ba |1,212 sqft

38 Tier Street

City Island

R New York RLS
180 Kilroe Street Closed

$750,000

Single Family Residence
4 bd | 2 ba |1,680 sqft

180 Kilroe Street

City Island

R New York RLS
180 Kilroe Street Closed

$750,000

Single Family Residence
4 bd | 2 ba |1,680 sqft

180 Kilroe Street

City Island

R New York RLS
1 Windward Lane #2 Closed

$798,400

Condo
2 bd | 3 ba |1,673 sqft

1 Windward Lane #2

City Island

R New York RLS
478 King Avenue Closed

$1,145,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 3 ba |2,294 sqft

478 King Avenue

City Island

R New York RLS
401 King Avenue Closed

$1,100,000

Single Family Residence
5 bd | 3 ba |2,272 sqft

401 King Avenue

City Island

R New York RLS
1 Windward Lane #1 Closed

$647,000

Condo
2 bd | 3 ba |1,585 sqft

1 Windward Lane #1

City Island

R New York RLS
170-190 Schofield Street #2-A Closed

$527,000

Condo
1 bd | 2 ba |1,100 sqft

170-190 Schofield Street #2-A

City Island

R New York RLS
467 King Avenue Closed

$913,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 3 ba |1,900 sqft

467 King Avenue

City Island

R New York RLS
61 Island Point #61 Closed

$600,000

Condo
2 bd | 2 ba |1,413 sqft

61 Island Point #61

City Island

Elegran Real Estate and Development RLS
400 King Avenue Closed

$600,000

Single Family Residence
4 bd | 2 ba |2,139 sqft

400 King Avenue

City Island

Compass RLS
59 EARLEY Street #1 Closed

$599,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 1 ba |1,300 sqft

59 EARLEY Street #1

City Island

Moda Realty RLS
61 BUCKLEY Street #1 Closed

$599,000

Single Family Residence
5 bd | 2 ba |2,000 sqft

61 BUCKLEY Street #1

City Island

Moda Realty RLS
170-190 Schofield Street #3-N Closed

$216,500

Condo
1 bd | 2 ba

170-190 Schofield Street #3-N

City Island

DJK Residential RLS

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average sale price in City Island?
Sale prices in City Island vary by property type and size. Visit the City Island market report for current median prices broken down by bedroom count.
How long does it take to sell in this neighborhood?
Days on market varies by season and pricing strategy. The City Island market report tracks average days on market so you can benchmark your listing.

Explore More

City Island Market ReportActive Listings in City IslandSell Your NYC PropertyNYC Buyer Guide
This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved.
Call Milton WhatsApp