Milton Coste

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

(917) 416-7433

NYC Neighborhood Comparison

Gerritsen Beach vs Sheepshead Bay

Side-by-side market data, transit, and neighborhood profiles to help you decide.

Brooklyn|Brooklyn

Gerritsen Beach

Brooklyn

Sheepshead Bay

Brooklyn

Median Sale Price
$560K
$758K
Median Rent
$0
$3K
Active Listings
20
319
Avg Days on Market
0 days
56 days
YoY Price Change
0.0%
-9.6%
Monthly Sales Volume
3
46

Detailed Comparison

MetricGerritsen BeachSheepshead Bay
Median Sale Price$560,000$757,500
Median Condo PriceN/A$450,000
Median Co-op PriceN/A$250,000
Median Rent$0$2,849
Active Listings20319
Rental Inventory169
Days on Market056
Price Cut Share19.0%13.5%
Monthly Sales Volume346
YoY Price Change0.0%-9.6%
YoY Rent Change0.0%-1.8%
YoY Inventory Change0.0%+24.1%
Subway LinesN/AN/A

Neighborhood Profiles

Gerritsen Beach

Gerritsen Beach is a waterfront neighborhood on Jamaica Bay featuring compact frame bungalows, two-story cottages, and brick homes, many with private boat docks along Gerritsen Creek and the Gotham Avenue Canal. The neighborhood maintains its coastal character with narrow streets, and residents access Manhattan via the B31 and B44 buses connecting to nearby subway lines.

View Full Market Report

Sheepshead Bay

Sheepshead Bay is a scenic waterfront neighborhood in Southern Brooklyn, famous for its fishing fleet, piers, and seafood restaurants. The area offers a unique maritime atmosphere with a relaxed, residential vibe. The real estate market features a mix of traditional multi-family brick houses, spacious pre-war cooperatives, and a growing number of modern luxury condominiums that offer stunning views of the bay and easy access to the beaches of Coney Island and Manhattan Beach.

View Full Market Report

Transit Access

Gerritsen Beach

No subway data available

Sheepshead Bay

No subway data available

Active Listings

Gerritsen Beach for sale

View all Gerritsen Beach listings

Sheepshead Bay for sale

View all Sheepshead Bay listings

More Comparisons

Need Help Choosing?

With 25+ years of experience across all five boroughs, I can help you find the right neighborhood for your lifestyle and budget.

Call Milton WhatsApp