23 Properties Found
For Sale · City Island
Advanced Search
1 active
Active Filters:
Closed
Closed
$848,000
Low-rise
551 Minnieford Avenue
City Island
4 bed
2 bath
1,851 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1901
#RLS20024929
#RLS20024929
View Details
Closed
$599,000
61 BUCKLEY Street #1
City Island
5 bed
2 bath
2,000 sqft
Single Family Residence
#RLS10097756
#RLS10097756
View Details
Closed
$646,000
Low-rise
38 Tier Street
City Island
3 bed
2 bath
1,212 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1920
#RLS10999533
#RLS10999533
View Details
Closed
$750,000
Low-rise
180 Kilroe Street
City Island
4 bed
2 bath
1,680 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1930
#RLS11006097
#RLS11006097
View Details
Closed
$750,000
Low-rise
180 Kilroe Street
City Island
4 bed
2 bath
1,680 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1930
#RLS10986396
#RLS10986396
View Details
Closed
$1,145,000
Low-rise
478 King Avenue
City Island
3 bed
3 bath
2,294 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1925
#RLS10945452
#RLS10945452
View Details
Closed
$647,000
Low-rise
1 Windward Lane #1
City Island
2 bed
3 bath
1,585 sqft
Condo · 1981
#RLS10830007
#RLS10830007
View Details
Closed
$599,000
59 EARLEY Street #1
City Island
3 bed
1 bath
1,300 sqft
Single Family Residence
#RLS10465396
#RLS10465396
View Details
Closed
$216,500
Low-rise
170-190 Schofield Street #3-N
City Island
1 bed
2 bath
Condo · 1990
#RLS10045752
#RLS10045752
View Details
Closed
$1,550,000
Low-rise
8 Tier Street
City Island
4 bed
2 bath
2,400 sqft
Multi Family · 1900
#RLS11022548
#RLS11022548
View Details
Closed
$625,000
Low-rise
723 KING Avenue
City Island
3 bed
2 bath
1,400 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1940
#RLS11021221
#RLS11021221
View Details
Closed
$1,250,000
Low-rise
16 Tier Street
City Island
5 bed
3 bath
2,535 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1940
#RLS11003624
#RLS11003624
View Details
Closed
$686,800
Low-rise
5 Windward Lane #5
City Island
2 bed
3 bath
1,639 sqft
Condo · 1981
#RLS10991315
#RLS10991315
View Details
Closed
$767,000
Low-rise
73 Caroll Street
City Island
3 bed
2 bath
1,620 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1901
#RLS10999532
#RLS10999532
View Details
Closed
$1,100,000
Low-rise
401 King Avenue
City Island
5 bed
3 bath
2,272 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1940
#RLS10882154
#RLS10882154
View Details
Closed
$675,000
Low-rise
148 Reville Street
City Island
3 bed
2 bath
1,424 sqft
Single Family Residence · 2005
#RLS11018297
#RLS11018297
View Details
Closed
$775,000
Low-rise
51 ISLAND Point #51
City Island
3 bed
4 bath
1,969 sqft
Condo
#RLS10986310
#RLS10986310
View Details
Closed
$660,000
Low-rise
383 KING Avenue
City Island
3 bed
3 bath
2,040 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1986
#RLS10979597
#RLS10979597
View Details
Closed
$527,000
Low-rise
170-190 Schofield Street #2-A
City Island
1 bed
2 bath
1,100 sqft
Condo · 1990
#RLS10798004
#RLS10798004
View Details
Closed
$798,400
Low-rise
1 Windward Lane #2
City Island
2 bed
3 bath
1,673 sqft
Condo · 1981
#RLS10979055
#RLS10979055
View Details
Closed
$600,000
Low-rise
400 King Avenue
City Island
4 bed
2 bath
2,139 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1920
#RLS10564746
#RLS10564746
View Details
Closed
$913,000
Low-rise
467 King Avenue
City Island
3 bed
3 bath
1,900 sqft
Single Family Residence · 1888
#RLS10738293
#RLS10738293
View Details
Closed
$600,000
Low-rise
61 Island Point #61
City Island
2 bed
2 bath
1,413 sqft
Condo · 2016
#RLS10745850
#RLS10745850
View Details
This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved.